Browse Forums Home Finance 1 Jan 12, 2012 2:00 pm So...basically, we want to buy a particular property we have fallen in love with, and we'd need to sell our own property in order to do it. And even then, we don't hold out much hope as the new property is more expensive than the price we expect we could get for our own property. Anyway, my question is...I just want to make sure I'm correct here, but...just for example you own a property and you achieve a sale of $340,000. This is NOT actually what you get, is it? You then pay about $9,050 in agent's commission (in QLD it's 5% for the first $18,000 and then 2.5% on the remaining balance, plus GST), and legals (though that's not much). So what you actually end up with is more like $330,000. And then say the property you want to BUY is also $340,000...that's not what you actually pay, is it? You then add on about $10,440 in stamp duty and also the legals, so what you're paying is more like $353,000. So suddenly there is this $20,000+ discrepancy even when on face value, the 2 properties are the SAME value!? Is this right or am I completely lost here? lol How the hell did I become a senior member!? I know nothing! Re: Is this right? (Buying AND selling lose you money?) 2Jan 12, 2012 2:05 pm It's not so much that you lose money because generally you are getting a better property upgrading, but if you are only looking at the $$$ figure & not anything else then yes you are losing money. A bank is a place that will lend you money only if you can prove that you don't need it... Re: Is this right? (Buying AND selling lose you money?) 4Jan 12, 2012 2:26 pm You are correct. It cost you to sell and it costs you to buy!!!! Agent's commission in Victoria are more negotiable than what you quoted for Queensland but maybe that includes advertising costs. In my area at least, agents charge a percentage (anywhere from 1% to around 3.5% but then charge all the extras for advertising, e.g. internet listing, professional photos, newspaper listings, sign boards, etc. separately. Re: Is this right? (Buying AND selling lose you money?) 5Jan 12, 2012 10:27 pm I wont say your "losing money"- but rather your PAYING for a service and your tax. Service - the agent Tax - Stamp duty. So really if you can find a buyer without a agent; or negotiate for a lower % on the commission it may work out....but the tax you can't avoid unless your entitled to some concession Also not to burst your bubble; depending on the original use of the property and age etc - CGT may be payable. Regards Michael Michael Chan | Australia wide Mortgage Broker Michael@ShapeHomeLoans.com.au | 1300 74 5626 | Fax: 02 8212 8909 http://www.ShapeHomeLoans.com.au Re: Is this right? (Buying AND selling lose you money?) 6Jan 13, 2012 12:56 am It sucks hey. And to top it off, if it's a buyers market it's usually not a seller's. So in other words, you may get the new house at a good price, but someone will with yours as well as it's value may have decreased due to the market (such as ours atm!!). So then you are losing money again! Re: Is this right? (Buying AND selling lose you money?) 7Jan 13, 2012 7:31 am grace_slick Is this right or am I completely lost here? lol Don't forget other costs such as removalists, your time looking for property, selling property, packing and unpacking. Demolition August 2009, Construction Started September 2009, Completed December 2010 Re: Is this right? (Buying AND selling lose you money?) 8Jan 14, 2012 1:41 pm and don't forget....how much did you pay for the house you are selling for ($340,000) when you purchased it years ago ! $200,000 maybe ? Re: Is this right? (Buying AND selling lose you money?) 9Jan 14, 2012 2:51 pm jj1 and don't forget....how much did you pay for the house you are selling for ($340,000) when you purchased it years ago ! $200,000 maybe ? and don't forget....how much you would pay for the house you are buying for ($510,000) when you could have purchased it years ago ! $300,000 maybe ? Demolition August 2009, Construction Started September 2009, Completed December 2010 Re: Is this right? (Buying AND selling lose you money?) 10Jan 16, 2012 4:43 pm Just as well you are not in Victoria. We pay the highest stamp duty in the country. I recently bought and sold and was out of pocket 50k including the ridiculous stamp duty cost of 34k. It forces people to stay put in less than ideal situations because the cost to move on is so prohibitive. Every time I move to a new house I loose a chunk of my equity on stamp duty (which is the greatest government rip off there is). Makes you want to rent - cost of moving as a tenant is removalists only... Re: Is this right? (Buying AND selling lose you money?) 11Jan 17, 2012 12:26 pm jj1 and don't forget....how much did you pay for the house you are selling for ($340,000) when you purchased it years ago ! $200,000 maybe ? HAH! I wish! We paid $337,000 in mid 2008. lol But yeah. We already included moving costs, depreciation / market issues, in our financial outlook. I just wanted to make sure I wasn't totally missing something in terms of the fees (stamp duty) and costs (agent commission and advertising). It just seems a lot, but I suppose compared to the amount you get from the sale, it's just a fraction. How the hell did I become a senior member!? I know nothing! Re: Is this right? (Buying AND selling lose you money?) 12Jan 17, 2012 12:29 pm Mozzie Just as well you are not in Victoria. We pay the highest stamp duty in the country. I recently bought and sold and was out of pocket 50k including the ridiculous stamp duty cost of 34k. It forces people to stay put in less than ideal situations because the cost to move on is so prohibitive. Every time I move to a new house I loose a chunk of my equity on stamp duty (which is the greatest government rip off there is). Makes you want to rent - cost of moving as a tenant is removalists only... WOAH! I knew VIC was high, but that just SUCKS! We thought QLD was bad now. When we bought our place in 2008, we hardly paid any stamp duty at all. We did pay SOME, as it was just before they took it away entirely for first home buyers, but it was only about $500 or something ridiculously low like that. But THIS time, it’s all different. If we paid $350,000 for a place, we’d be losing an extra $9,000+ just in NOTHING! What is it FOR anyway? Who does it benefit (well, obviously I know that, but for what specific purpose does the government claim it’s used for?) How the hell did I become a senior member!? I know nothing! I've just had a look at the website. The company are just building broker's. There are plenty of similar companies that basically draw your plans (they own them so you… 8 12123 As a tradesmen get a private inspector although I don't think there worth it in their profession themselves the reminder they serve to the tradesmen doing the work is… 3 28248 Yeah sorry man, thats always been my fear during this first time build.. we have literally just hit lockup as-well, so ive been praying for no issues. Our mortgage /… 3 3370 |