Mar 16, 2015 8:44 pm
I am in the market for a pool pump and have seen quite a few pumps on the market that claim to be eco "EFFICIENT" with running costs.
I read that a "Typical" (Whatever that means) size pool annual running cost would cost around $1,200 to run where as an eco equivalent would only cost $90 to run the whole year. This is apparently achieved with brush less technology and the pump runs much slower over a greater time per day.
My pool plumber told me that this is all marketing hype and that the cost of such a pump is not worth the investment.
Can anyone share their experiences?
My Swimming Pool Build.
Concrete Swimming Pool - Owner Builder in South Australia
Re: Eco Pool Pumps vs single speed power guzzlers2
Mar 16, 2015 9:02 pm
It's hard to be specific without understanding the system but I have designed many pumped systems for water authorities over the years.
The general rule is that the best way in saving operational costs is to specify pumps that run the system as slowly as possible while still meeting peak flows.
Although it is possible to build pumping stations with two large pumps (one to run and the other as standby) it is often better to build stations with three or more lower capacity pumps, or install variable speed drives. Typical payback for the substantial initial additional cost can be as little as one year.
The Harder You Try - the Luckier You Get !
Informative, Amusing, and Opinionated Blog - Over 600 posts on all aspects of building a new house.
Re: Eco Pool Pumps vs single speed power guzzlers3
Mar 19, 2015 8:23 pm
I would suggest looking at a variable speed drive pump. If you conduct a You Tube search there is a clip comparing the efficiency of a variable speed pump with a standard type of pump. I recall it is american, but the principles apply.
I would also recommend contacting the swimming pools and spa's association in your state. They have some great info.
Re: Eco Pool Pumps vs single speed power guzzlers4
Mar 19, 2015 9:43 pm
It totally depends on what it is operating. If it is a basic pool instillation without water features , infloor cleaning etc a single quality speed pump with brushless motor draws exactly the same as A variable speed . You need to check flow rates for chlorinators & heaters when running a variable speed as they may not work on lowest speeds .
The comparisons are between the worst single speed pump with worn bearings & poor hydraulic design against the best case for the other .
I use both types but spend some time with each job evaluating merits of both.
Re: Eco Pool Pumps vs single speed power guzzlers6
Mar 21, 2015 8:40 pm
The pool plumber exclusively uses and recommends Waterco........ are they any good?
I have no idea which brand is good and which one is not.
All feedback appreciated.
Re: Eco Pool Pumps vs single speed power guzzlers7
Mar 21, 2015 8:54 pm
Waterco is a Australian owned asx listed company. I have always insisted on waterco equipment for my pools. Your pool guy is someone you trust
Building MJH Garden Retreat modified Lot 305 Wattleridge Crescent Kellyville
Sign in or Join to reply to this Topic
sxwallacPentair or Virion Pool pumps and controllers?Pentair or Virion Pool pumps and controllers?
Hi Guys, Deciding Viron vs Pentair: pool pump and autiomation, and need help please! We have the choice of either - A Virion Connect 10, Virion P520XT pump (2 year…