Re: Floorplan feedback please!2
Mar 04, 2018 4:39 pm
Looks good, if your custom designing your house check out the yourhome website. My custom design house is pretty much copied of the plans from that website, main living areas to the north and east and bedrooms along east and south. Top floor middle bedroom may get hot, if i interpreted correctly that has a west facing window so may need longer eaves or a some sort of shading device.
Bathrooms could be in the west side, but makes sense to have all the wet areas in the same side as you have now.
Re: Floorplan feedback please!3
Mar 04, 2018 6:20 pm
Thanks for your comments and I’ll check out the yourhome website. The bedrooms are on the east, master to the south because of views and bathrooms on the west. Unfortunately we’re south facing rear so have put rumpus to the north for winter sun. Thanks!
Re: Floorplan feedback please!4
Mar 04, 2018 6:27 pm
Yeah, great website, we have two lIving areas one has a northerly aspect and the second south facing, I call it the summer room if the other one gets too hot going for passive heating and cooling design first before deciding on mechanical heating and cooling. Time will tell.
Re: Floorplan feedback please!5
Mar 04, 2018 8:02 pm
Nice plan - I've had a look over and there's not much I can find to fault with it. A north-to-front block is the hardest to design for, but I think you've done well within your restrictions, and I quite like what you've got there.
One minor suggestion re the upstairs bathroom layout - having the shower behind the opening door can be a real pain (you end up with a door clash) - in theory it shouldn't mater much, but it seems to be much worse in practice (we currently have this arrangement and it can be awkward at times). You might consider switching the bathtub and the shower, or even the shower and the toilet - it's possible to have a window in a shower (although that might not be to your taste), or to maybe change the window arrangement.
I did find it a little difficult to work out some of your loading lines, though - might it be possible to align the eastern and western walls at the northern end with their lower counterparts (guest room and garage)? I appreciate that you mightn't be able to do this for setback/overshadowing, or might not want to for dressing reasons, but depending on your construction materials as it is might might require structural steel which might otherwise be avoided.
Re: Floorplan feedback please!6
Mar 05, 2018 9:13 am
Just a few comments: and I appreciate cost can be a killer ...
It looks really nice.
But - as I say - it looks good. One idea - don't exclude top range Synthetic grass for back area - especially around pool. It looks awesome and can handle a reasonable traffic flow. Simple to maintain and 10 years lifespan. Try to find the 4 metre wide - it looks better. I wouldn't go the cheap and nasty stuff though ... Everyone has tiles/pavers - which are nice - but I love our synthetic grass - so does the dog. Just for the look - if nothing else.
Re: Floorplan feedback please!7
Mar 05, 2018 9:50 am
Jacks Please get Professional advice On the Design, Engineering & Associated costs
Also try to make a feature of the stairs ..BTW those stairs in your plan don't even work nor can they be built?
If you are using a design app then make sure it works in 3D, you might want to try Sketchup 3D stairs,
and if you see a configuration you like reach out for the 3D (BIM Data) Construction & Engineering Details/Drawings.
Here's the details for the Spiral Staircase example
OT what you want to avoid is going to site/Construction with details that can't be build because
1. It delays Construction
2. Incurs Post contract Variations & Extra Costs
3.If it later requires alterations onsite or structural repairs it will cost you.
Re: Floorplan feedback please!8
Mar 06, 2018 7:49 am
That's funny - the stairs look ok to me. I like a "landing" half way up - and wide "slats/steps".
Why can't they be built SBG ? I've seen stairs like this. I'd never get a spiral staircase - might look "trendy" but you want something for now and the future. Easy to access - and easy to use. For old and young.
Style isn't everything imo.
Re: Floorplan feedback please!9
Mar 06, 2018 8:29 am
Landing should show on Both GF & 1F Plans?
Look at the arrows... Count the steps 29? for a 2S house? ...Though it would be easier to look at the 3D Model
I've include the spiral stairs details for no other reason than it is the first image on Sketchup warehouse
LOL Would you prefer something more spectacular, like Escher Stairs though there is no engineering and it can't be built ?
Re: Floorplan feedback please!11
Mar 07, 2018 12:58 pm
IMO, Imaging Technology has blurred the boundaries of what we can and can't build..don't be fooled
Architect & Builders are happy to market/spin Images/Designs that ultimately cost more to build
Engineering for me at least is becoming the practical applications
of that technology ( using, Data,, Proofs & Cost Optimization, etc,etc). Tech Drawing is dead and so is latin
Re: Floorplan feedback please!12
Mar 08, 2018 8:36 pm
Thanks all for your feedback! I’ll take it all on board! Apologies for the confusion regarding the stairs - this is a rough mock up in Magicplan to show layout of rooms and furniture and does not show the exact structure of the stairs. They are straight forward stairs with a landing halfway. Thanks everyone!
Re: Floorplan feedback please!13
Mar 08, 2018 8:50 pm
Thanks, When you are ready to move to the next stage
Elevations, Site Plan, Retaining walls & alternative details/costs for Engineering
feel free to reach out.
Sign in or Join to reply to this Topic
DamNitaFloorplan feedback/recommendations pleaseFloorplan feedback/recommendations please
I don't like that there is no buffer from the living room / kitchen to the bedrooms 3 & 4. I'm all about privacy and this just does't look right. There are many ways to…
seechangeHybrid floors - any feedback?Hybrid floors - any feedback?
We had our heart set on timber floors but as we are havinghydronic heating/cooling in the slab the range is limited (a selection of engineered oak) none of which we really…